Skip to main content

Deborah Edgerly Is Scapegoat For Common Council Practice Of Influencing City Staff

What I find so "funny" -- and by that I mean strange -- about the entire rush to oust Oakland City Administrator Deborah Edgerly, is that she not only does have the City Charter-endowed right to impact what City staff -- including the police department -- but she'e being scapegoated for an action that certain City Council members have been known for: calling city staff to have them act on something. The difference is that Miss E can do that, but City Councilmembers can't do that.

But it happens on a regular basis. I think this is a real flaw in the City Charter in that Councilmembers should be able to have some sway over what is done by City Staff, but only to a certain extent. But the fact is that at least one Councilmember was known to call city staffers and push through contracts for relatives. That's a fact.

The East Bay Express, and some other bloggers just don't know Oakland at all.

Comments

Charlie2 said…
Zennie, you can't cut the tip off the iceberg (more of it will simply rise into view). You are right, corruption and greed go far beyond Edgerly. When she tried to protect a guy apparently negotiating a gun deal with a drug boss, though, she finally crossed a line even the mayor could not ignore -- although we'll see how much backbone he has.
Zennie said…
Ah. I'm not saying that the city's "rife with corruption, so much as what Miss E's being blamed for is really 1) her job and 2) a common habit. If you want to call that bad, so be it.

But let's look at it this way. Many who voted for Nancy Nadel to return to her City Council seat, did so because they said "she was effective at getting things done."

Think about that. That means she has a good relationship with the City Administrator and the City Staff. Councilmember Nadel does not have a staff large enough to provide every public service, so she has to call persons in the appropriate departments.

Here's where it gets tricky. She can ask for help or assistance but she can't try to control what they do. Now, one Councilmember has done this in the past -- the recent past. And they're still with us.

Now do you call that corruption? Then if you do, you must also say your City Council Person can only act via being corrupt.

Now, let's add that what the CAO has done -- she didn't walk into a negotiation regarding a gun deal -- is really within her Charter-given powers. What's going on is someone over at the Oakland Police is twisting the story to stick it to Deborah Edgerly.
carlon yoder said…
zennie...as I understand it, its not so much that Deb Edge is, as you say, "trying to ask for help or assistance" from other city staff and departments. Her most serious charge is tipping off her nephew to an investigation. Those are two very different things.

Circumventing civil service rules in order to get a family member hired riles those of us in the union who had to go through the civil service hoops to get our jobs. Those rules are put in place to make the process as fair and unbiased as possible. How do you define nepotism? I'm curious.

Finally, can you be more specific about which councilmember is doing the same thing and exactly what the situation is? I'd be curious. If they are breaking rules that are in place, they should also face consequences.

Popular posts from this blog

Alex Castro, Electronic Arts VP, Is Oakland’s “Fake Joe Tuman”, “Crocker Mom”

Alex Castro, is currently Vice President Of Product Management At Electronic Arts, and a fairly-well-known and legendary tech executive, regularly quoted in a number of industry publications. But Alex Castro’s also an Oakland resident who has the terrible habit of going online, making traceble email accounts from his Electronic Arts office, and posing as someone […] from WordPress http://ift.tt/1fVkWP9 via IFTTT

Event: Jog For Jill San Francisco Run September 12th Golden Gate Park

Cal Women's Rowing Team member Jill Costello passed away from complications due to lung cancer on June 24th 2010 and at the age of 21. A San Francisco event and run called Jog For Jill has been established and will be held this Sunday, September 12th at 5 PM. Two members of the Cal Women's Crew team were at the Cal vs. Davis football game wearing Jog For Jill shirts, and were kind enough to provide the video interview above. Below are the other details from the event website, where you're encouraged to pre-register here CLICK FOR SITE : Pre-Registration: Online/$25 Day of Registration: 4:00 p.m./$30 Shotgun Start: 5:00 p.m. After run/walk celebration: 6:00 p.m.- 8:30 p.m. Event Location: Golden Gate Park Music Concourse Bandshell S Tea Garden Drive San Francisco, California 94118 Participants are encouraged to pre-register. Only pre-registered participants will be guaranteed a walk/run T-shirt. T-shirts will be limited to the first 2500 day of regis

Oakland Mayor's Race: LWV Forum Draws Oakland's Older Folks

Oakland Mayor's Race Forum first take. (Which means, there's going to be more of these posts on last night, because a lot was happening.) This just in: The Oakland Tribune's out of touch with Oakland. A number of attendees of the 450 estimated said they learned of the Oakland League Of Women Voters via "the newspaper." All of the people who made that statement were over 50 years old. Still, the forum, which attracted every candidate except Dr. Terrance Candell, was a success. The auditorium at 300 Lakeside Drive seats 380 people, so if you do the math, it was about 70 over capacity. The crowd was a happy mix of supporters of candidates and long-time observers of the Oakland political scene. The one complaint they had was there wasn't enough time to hear what the candidates were about. That wasn't because there were too many candidates, but due to the format. Either Oakland Tribune Editor Martin Reynolds or the League of Women Voter