Skip to main content

Flawed Oak To Ninth Referendum Killed By City Attorney, But Lawsuit Challenge To Action Dropped

Flawed Oak To Ninth Referendum Killed By City Attorney, But Lawsuit Challenge To Action Dropped



In October of 2006, and pointing to a major flaw in a referendum to delay the controversial Oak to Ninth Development Project, Oakland City Attorney John Russo killed the petition drive. The reasons he gave at the time were:

Here are the facts:

The City of Oakland is required, upon request, to provide a date-stamped, certified,
hard-copy of any ordinance;

The Referendum Committee finally requested a certified, hard-copy of the ordinance
on September 8
th
–several weeks AFTER the signatures had been turned in;

The Referendum Committee claims they were told by the City Clerk’s office they could
download the ordinance from the website, but cannot tell us who specifically gave
them this direction;

The copy of the ordinance that the Referendum Committee used read “NOT
ACCURATE –TO BE UPDATED” on the Table of Contents;

Even though one of the primary concerns for the Committee was a potential loss of
park land, the petitioners did not provide the maps attached as exhibits to the
ordinance to the public.
The fact is the Referendum Committee leaders did not do their homework and neither the
public nor their volunteers were well-served by their failure. It’s clear that the Referendum
Committee’s heedless rush to get signatures resulted in part, if not totally, in the
embarrassing situation they find themselves in today.
It’s ironic and bordering on strange to be attacked by the League of Women Voters’ attorneys
for upholding state disclosure laws and the protections those laws provide the public.
Transparency is a value that must apply equally to all who participate in our democratic
process. Transparency can be tough. No one can or should put themselves above it—no
matter how passionately they believe in the righteousness of their cause.


This angered Oakland/Berkeley political activists and set off a lawsuit challenging Russo's action in court. But on November 9th, the opponents, the Oak to 9th Referendum Committee, dropped their lawsuit due to lack of money, and that even though the group held a kind of fund-raiser on September 15th. The leaders of this group..

Naomi Schiff, Oakland Heritage Alliance
Helen Hutchison, League of Women Voters of Oakland
James E Vann, Coalition of Advocates for Lake Merritt

Which obtained the following endorsements..

League of Women Voters
Sierra Club
Coalition of Advocates for Lake Merritt (CALM)
Piedmont Avenue Neighborhood Improvement League (PANIL)
The Green Party
East Bay Bicycle Coalition
Jack London District Association
Fifth Avenue Institute
Pamela Drake, past president MGO Democratic Club
Oakland Heritage Alliance

Lost a huge battle. While I personally favor the project as a great place for baseball, their concerns were certainly -- for the most part -- valid. They could have gotten more traction out of fighting for it as a home for the Oakland A's, and perhaps gained the City Attorney and others as alies.

And that's the point. The leaders of the opposition should have had an alternative plan. Someone at this point will think "The city can't afford baseball" but my counter is the project would have generated enough re-sale land revenue to pay for a ballpark project. It's just that this wasn't explored.

Oh well.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Alex Castro, Electronic Arts VP, Is Oakland’s “Fake Joe Tuman”, “Crocker Mom”

Alex Castro, is currently Vice President Of Product Management At Electronic Arts, and a fairly-well-known and legendary tech executive, regularly quoted in a number of industry publications. But Alex Castro’s also an Oakland resident who has the terrible habit of going online, making traceble email accounts from his Electronic Arts office, and posing as someone […] from WordPress http://ift.tt/1fVkWP9 via IFTTT

Interview: Imani, Chef Owner of Roasted and Raw RoastedRaw.com, For Oakland Restaurant Week 2023

Interview: Imani, Chef Owner of Roasted and Raw RoastedRaw.com, For Oakland Restaurant Week 2023 Interview: Imani, Chef Owner of Roasted and Raw RoastedRaw.com, For Oakland Restaurant Week 2023. Imani Greer gets a highlight in The Oakland Post: Chef Imani Greer, a culinary entrepreneur, has created quite a stir — and menu — for the Bay Area’s vegan-loving community with the opening of his new Roasted and Raw (R&R) restaurant near Oakland’s Jack London Square. I am proud to welcome him to Zennie62Media for Oakland Restaurant Week 2023. Stay tuned. via YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QvMqVWLAH4

Event: Jog For Jill San Francisco Run September 12th Golden Gate Park

Cal Women's Rowing Team member Jill Costello passed away from complications due to lung cancer on June 24th 2010 and at the age of 21. A San Francisco event and run called Jog For Jill has been established and will be held this Sunday, September 12th at 5 PM. Two members of the Cal Women's Crew team were at the Cal vs. Davis football game wearing Jog For Jill shirts, and were kind enough to provide the video interview above. Below are the other details from the event website, where you're encouraged to pre-register here CLICK FOR SITE : Pre-Registration: Online/$25 Day of Registration: 4:00 p.m./$30 Shotgun Start: 5:00 p.m. After run/walk celebration: 6:00 p.m.- 8:30 p.m. Event Location: Golden Gate Park Music Concourse Bandshell S Tea Garden Drive San Francisco, California 94118 Participants are encouraged to pre-register. Only pre-registered participants will be guaranteed a walk/run T-shirt. T-shirts will be limited to the first 2500 day of regis