Skip to main content

Judge Orders Oak To Ninth EIR To Be Rewritten - Tribune

Some who are against the Oak to Ninth project will claim this as a victory, but that's wrong. This doens't throw out the Oakland City Council's approval of the project, as reported elsewhere.

Judge tosses Oak-to-Ninth impact report

New development project write-up in works taking into account court's concerns

By Kelly Rayburn, STAFF WRITER - OAKLAND TRIBUNE

Article Last Updated: 11/21/2007 02:42:49 AM PST

OAKLAND — Two sides are claiming victory this week after a Superior Court judge issued a ruling on two lawsuits that challenged Oakland's massive Oak-to-Ninth development project.

The legal battle pitted the city and project developer Oakland Harbor Partners against the Coalition of Advocates for Lake Merritt and the Oakland Heritage Alliance over questions of whether the city adequately considered the impact the project will have on the surrounding environment.

The two groups filed separate lawsuits. Judge Jo-Lynne Q. Lee ruled on them simultaneously Friday.

In the ruling, Judge Lee directed the city to "void" its approval of the project's environmental impact report.
"We're pleased," said Brian Gaffney, attorney for the Coalition of Advocates for Lake Merritt. "My clients are pleased."
The ruling on the environmental impact report was made on what the city considers narrow grounds, however.

City officials say the concerns the judge brought up can be addressed in time.

"It's good," said Alex Katz, spokesman for City Attorney John Russo. "We see it as a win for the city. ... The court upheld the city's position on a majority of issues. It's a big project so it's not unusual for the court to ask the city to amend parts of the EIR."
Katz noted that the judge's ruling to void the environmental document was largely related to the document's analysis of the impact other projects will have in the Oak-to-Ninth area, not the impact the development project itself will have.

The judge also ruled against the Oakland Heritage Alliance in its effort to protect the Ninth Avenue Terminal, most of which would be lost in the city's current plans.

The judge did, however, say analysis of seismic impacts was incomplete.

Project supporters said the ruling did not put the success of Oak-to-Ninth in question. "I doubt it will jeopardize the project," said Councilmember Patricia Kernighan (Grand Lake-Chinatown), adding, "Most problems that can be identified in an EIR can be mitigated, so I anticipate that's what will take place."

There was no word Tuesday from city staff on how long it might take before a new environmental document, one taking the judge's concerns into account, would be back before the City Council.

Oak-to-Ninth developers envision a project that will convert an underused waterfront area east of Jack London Square into a vibrant mini-city.

Plans include building 3,100 homes, retail and commercial areas, about 30 acres of open space and two renovated marinas.
Detractors have decried what they say is insufficient public waterfront access, a lack of affordable housing and poor planning for traffic congestion and air pollution.

The project has been tied up in legal challenges since it was approved in July 2006.

In a separate case, a group collected more than 25,000 signatures, hoping to overturn the City Council's vote through a referendum.

The signatures were ruled invalid by Russo, however, when he determined the wrong version of the ordinance was circulated during signature gathering.

Last week, the referendum group dropped a case seeking to reverse Russo's decision, saying it ran out of money as a December court date approached.

As for the environmental challenges, attorney Arthur Levy, who represented the Oakland Heritage Alliance, said he was disappointed in the ruling on the Ninth Avenue Terminal.

But he added the judge's ruling will give the council the opportunity to reconsider its plans for the terminal since it will have to revisit the overall project.

Michael Ghielmetti, president of Signature Properties, which joined Reynolds and Brown to form Oakland Harbor Partners, said "overall we're pleased" with the ruling.

"There's always something that can be studied further," he said. "I think on the whole of it, we're excited."

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Alex Castro, Electronic Arts VP, Is Oakland’s “Fake Joe Tuman”, “Crocker Mom”

Alex Castro, is currently Vice President Of Product Management At Electronic Arts, and a fairly-well-known and legendary tech executive, regularly quoted in a number of industry publications. But Alex Castro’s also an Oakland resident who has the terrible habit of going online, making traceble email accounts from his Electronic Arts office, and posing as someone […] from WordPress http://ift.tt/1fVkWP9 via IFTTT

Event: Jog For Jill San Francisco Run September 12th Golden Gate Park

Cal Women's Rowing Team member Jill Costello passed away from complications due to lung cancer on June 24th 2010 and at the age of 21. A San Francisco event and run called Jog For Jill has been established and will be held this Sunday, September 12th at 5 PM. Two members of the Cal Women's Crew team were at the Cal vs. Davis football game wearing Jog For Jill shirts, and were kind enough to provide the video interview above. Below are the other details from the event website, where you're encouraged to pre-register here CLICK FOR SITE : Pre-Registration: Online/$25 Day of Registration: 4:00 p.m./$30 Shotgun Start: 5:00 p.m. After run/walk celebration: 6:00 p.m.- 8:30 p.m. Event Location: Golden Gate Park Music Concourse Bandshell S Tea Garden Drive San Francisco, California 94118 Participants are encouraged to pre-register. Only pre-registered participants will be guaranteed a walk/run T-shirt. T-shirts will be limited to the first 2500 day of regis...

Interview: Imani, Chef Owner of Roasted and Raw RoastedRaw.com, For Oakland Restaurant Week 2023

Interview: Imani, Chef Owner of Roasted and Raw RoastedRaw.com, For Oakland Restaurant Week 2023 Interview: Imani, Chef Owner of Roasted and Raw RoastedRaw.com, For Oakland Restaurant Week 2023. Imani Greer gets a highlight in The Oakland Post: Chef Imani Greer, a culinary entrepreneur, has created quite a stir — and menu — for the Bay Area’s vegan-loving community with the opening of his new Roasted and Raw (R&R) restaurant near Oakland’s Jack London Square. I am proud to welcome him to Zennie62Media for Oakland Restaurant Week 2023. Stay tuned. via YouTube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8QvMqVWLAH4